GOATvs

GOATvs › Books › Face-off

Crime and Punishment vs The Brothers Karamazov

Which book? Pick one and see how the world splits.

What the votes say

The world picks Crime and Punishment over The Brothers Karamazov, 55% to 45%. Crime and Punishment is #11 of the 400 books in the world ranking and The Brothers Karamazov #23; among the 4 by Fyodor Dostoyevsky, they are #1 and #2.

The case for each

Crime and Punishment: Dostoevsky's novel of Raskolnikov, a poor former student in St Petersburg who murders an old pawnbroker to prove a theory about extraordinary men, then cannot escape his own conscience.

The Brothers Karamazov: Dostoevsky's last novel, finished in 1880: three brothers and the murder of their father, with the chapter of the Grand Inquisitor. Freud called it the most magnificent novel ever written.

Side by side

Crime and PunishmentThe Brothers Karamazov
World rank#11#23
AuthorFyodor DostoyevskyFyodor Dostoyevsky
Written18651878
LanguageRussianRussian

Related face-offs

See the Top 100