GOATvs › Footballers › Face-off
Paolo Maldini vs Roberto Carlos
Which player? Pick one and see how the world splits.
- Paolo Maldini Italy · 1968– 52% · #17 in the world
- Roberto Carlos Brazil · 1973– 48% · #18 in the world
What the votes say
Too close to call: the world picks Paolo Maldini over Roberto Carlos by just 52% to 48%. Paolo Maldini is #17 of the 300 footballers in the world ranking, and #1 of the 23 from Italy. Roberto Carlos is #18, and #5 of the 31 from Brazil.
The case for each
Paolo Maldini: Italy's left back of a generation, a one-club man at AC Milan from 1985 to 2009: 902 games, five European Cups and Champions Leagues, seven Serie A titles, and a reputation for winning the ball without needing to slide.
Roberto Carlos: Brazil's left back of the same years, built on speed and shooting: a 2002 World Cup, three Champions Leagues with Real Madrid and the famous swerving free kick against France at Le Tournoi in 1997.
Side by side
| Paolo Maldini | Roberto Carlos | |
|---|---|---|
| World rank | #17 | #18 |
| Country | Italy | Brazil |
| Born | 1968 | 1973 |