GOATvs

GOATvs › Games › Face-off

Mafia vs Mafia II

Which game? Pick one and see how the world splits.

What the votes say

Too close to call: the world picks Mafia over Mafia II by just 50.1% to 49.9%. Mafia is #309 of the 1,000 games in the world ranking, and #88 of the 254 from the 2000s. Mafia II is #311, and #127 of the 391 from the 2010s.

Side by side

MafiaMafia II
World rank#309#311
Year20022010
GenreThird-person shooter / First-person shooterThird-person shooter / Action-adventure game

Related face-offs

See the Top 100