GOATvs

GOATvs › Games › Face-off

Red Dead Redemption vs Grand Theft Auto

Which game? Pick one and see how the world splits.

What the votes say

A clear win: the world picks Red Dead Redemption over Grand Theft Auto, 76% to 24%. Red Dead Redemption is #11 of the 1,000 games in the world ranking, and #6 of the 391 from the 2010s. Grand Theft Auto is #321, and #39 of the 116 from the 1990s.

The case for each

Red Dead Redemption: Rockstar's 2010 western: former outlaw John Marston is forced by federal agents to hunt down his old gang as the frontier closes in 1911. Its ending is one of the most talked about in games; Red Dead Redemption 2 followed in 2018.

Grand Theft Auto: The 1997 original from DMA Design, later Rockstar North: a top-down crime game where players steal cars and take jobs for gangs across Liberty City, San Andreas and Vice City. The outcry over its violence made it famous before it was a hit.

Side by side

Red Dead RedemptionGrand Theft Auto
World rank#11#321
Year20101998
GenreAction-adventure gameAction-adventure game

Related face-offs

See the Top 100