GOATvs

GOATvs › Games › Face-off

Silent Hill 2 vs Silent Hill f

Which game? Pick one and see how the world splits.

What the votes say

A clear win: the world picks Silent Hill 2 over Silent Hill f, 77% to 23%. Silent Hill 2 is #42 of the 1,100 video games in the world ranking, and #13 of the 302 from the 2000s. Silent Hill f is #994, and #167 of the 199 from the 2020s.

The case for each

Silent Hill 2: Team Silent's 2001 psychological horror: James Sunderland comes to Silent Hill after a letter from a wife dead for three years. Pyramid Head, the fog and Akira Yamaoka's music made it a landmark of the genre.

Silent Hill f: Konami's 2025 Silent Hill, set not in the American town but in 1960s rural Japan: the schoolgirl Hinako Shimizu in a town swallowed by fog and red flowers, written by Ryukishi07.

Side by side

Silent Hill 2Silent Hill f
World rank#42#994
Year20012025
GenreSurvival horrorSurvival horror

See the Top 100