GOATvs

GOATvs › Games › Face-off

Super Mario Odyssey vs Super Mario Galaxy

Which game? Pick one and see how the world splits.

What the votes say

Too close to call: the world picks Super Mario Odyssey over Super Mario Galaxy by just 53% to 47%. Super Mario Odyssey is #55 of the 1,100 video games in the world ranking, and #20 of the 401 from the 2010s. Super Mario Galaxy is #85, and #29 of the 302 from the 2000s.

The case for each

Super Mario Odyssey: Nintendo's 2017 Switch game: Mario throws Cappy, a living hat, to take over enemies and objects across kingdoms from New Donk City to the Moon. A sandbox return to the style of Super Mario 64.

Super Mario Galaxy: Nintendo's 2007 Wii game: Mario runs around tiny planets with their own gravity to save Princess Peach, with Rosalina and her comet observatory. Often rated one of the best platformers ever made.

Side by side

Super Mario OdysseySuper Mario Galaxy
World rank#55#85
Year20172007
Genre3D platform game / Collect-a-thon platformer3D platform game

See the Top 100