GOATvs

GOATvs › Movies › Face-off

GoodFellas vs Casino

Which movie? Pick one and see how the world splits.

What the votes say

A clear win: the world picks GoodFellas over Casino, 72% to 28%. GoodFellas is #6 of the 1,800 movies in the world ranking and Casino #115; among the 17 by Martin Scorsese, they are #1 and #6.

The case for each

GoodFellas: Scorsese's 1990 mob film from Pileggi's book: Henry Hill's life in a New York crime family, from teenage errand boy to informant. Joe Pesci won the Oscar, and the long Copacabana tracking shot is still studied.

Casino: Scorsese's 1995 return to Nicholas Pileggi, De Niro and Pesci: a Las Vegas casino run for the Chicago mob in the 1970s, told through Ace Rothstein, with Sharon Stone in an Oscar-nominated role. Three hours of money, skimming and collapse.

Side by side

GoodFellasCasino
World rank#6#115
Year19901995
GenreBiography / Crime / DramaCrime / Drama
DirectorMartin ScorseseMartin Scorsese
Running time146 min178 min

See the Top 100