GOATvs

GOATvs › Movies › Face-off

Shutter Island vs Sinners

Which movie? Pick one and see how the world splits.

What the votes say

Too close to call: the world picks Shutter Island over Sinners by just 50.1% to 49.9%. Shutter Island is #115 of the 1,100 movies in the world ranking, and #5 of the 13 by Martin Scorsese. Sinners is #117, and #1 of the 4 by Ryan Coogler.

Side by side

Shutter IslandSinners
World rank#115#117
Year20102025
GenreMystery / ThrillerHorror
DirectorMartin ScorseseRyan Coogler
Running time139 min137 min

See the Top 100