GOATvs › Songs · English & Global › Face-off
With or Without You vs Master of Puppets
Which song? Pick one and see how the world splits.
- With or Without You U2 50.1% · #184 in the world
- Master of Puppets Metallica 49.9% · #186 in the world
What the votes say
Too close to call: the world picks With or Without You over Master of Puppets by just 50.1% to 49.9%. With or Without You is #184 of the 3,402 English & Global songs in the world ranking, and #2 of the 27 by U2. Master of Puppets is #186, and #4 of the 37 by Metallica.
Side by side
| With or Without You | Master of Puppets | |
|---|---|---|
| World rank | #184 | #186 |
| Artist | U2 | Metallica |