GOATvs › Footballers › Face-off
Franz Beckenbauer vs Paolo Maldini
Which player? Pick one and see how the world splits.
- Franz Beckenbauer West Germany · 1945–2024 47% · #21 in the world
- Paolo Maldini Italy · 1968– 53% · #17 in the world
What the votes say
Too close to call: the world picks Paolo Maldini over Franz Beckenbauer by just 53% to 47%. Paolo Maldini is #17 of the 300 footballers in the world ranking, and #1 of the 23 from Italy. Franz Beckenbauer is #21.
The case for each
Franz Beckenbauer: Der Kaiser, the Bayern Munich and West Germany sweeper who turned defending into attacking from the back: World Cup winner as captain in 1974 and as coach in 1990, three straight European Cups (1974-76) and two Ballon d'Ors.
Paolo Maldini: The model for every modern defender after Beckenbauer's era: one club, AC Milan, from 1985 to 2009, 902 games, five European titles and seven Serie A titles, plus 126 caps and the 1994 World Cup final for Italy.
Side by side
| Franz Beckenbauer | Paolo Maldini | |
|---|---|---|
| World rank | #21 | #17 |
| Country | West Germany | Italy |
| Born | 1945 | 1968 |
| Ballon d'Or | 2 | — |